Hey music maker!
For the last few weeks, a reminder has gone off on my phone every morning. It says, "Create like a child."
I set it because of my kids. Right now they're into Legos and blaster boards, and they just build stuff. Then they run over to show us, all excited. They're not worried about whether it's good.
That's how I was when I started producing in college.
Everything I made was something to learn from. Almost daily, I would try an idea, take note of the growth, and be happy I made something. Then I would study and repeat the process.
I want to get back to that.
About a week ago, I came across a video of Tyler, the Creator saying that same line, but he added a second part: "Create like a child. Edit like a scientist."
That was the piece I was missing. I shared it on Threads, and it took off. It showed me a lot of us needed that reminder.
In today's issue:
A verse that gets a lot of color out of very few chord changes
Why the critic and the scientist are two different voices
Two arrangement moves you can try in your version two

💿 VAULT PICK
"Brass in Pocket" by The Pretenders
Key: A major
Verse progression (Nashville numbers)
1 - 1sus2 - 1sus4 - 1 (repeat)
6m - 6m(add4) - 4/6 - 6m
4 - 4/5
The foundation of this progression 1 - 6m - 4 - 6m - 4 - 5.
The chords under this verse barely move, but the section is interesting, and that's what makes it worth studying.
It starts on the 1 with A in the bass. Then one note inside the chord moves, so you hear 1sus2 and 1sus4 around the plain 1.
Harmony Move: Color variation in the chords over a simple and static bass line.
The 6m gets the same treatment. One note is added to turn it into a 6m(add4). Then comes the 4, but with F# still in the bass (4/6), so the overall bass barely moves at all.
At the end, it lands on a root position 4. Then the D chord stays on top while the bass moves up to E (4/5). You get some of the pull of the 5 with different harmonic color.
When you look at the foundation, it's a simple progression. The slash chords and sus chords are what give it the groove.

🧠 IDEA OF THE WEEK
Decoded: Create like a child. Edit like a scientist.
When I sit down to make something, the critic shows up early. You know the voice.
It hands out rude comments like: "That's corny." "That's nowhere near the songs I love."
It holds my new idea up next to finished records, and a new idea loses that fight every time.
Took me a while to see this, but the critic and the scientist are two different voices.
The critic gives a verdict, and that usually kills my creativity.
The scientist asks questions, and those questions lead to a test. Then another test. That's how a song develops.
A tennis coach named Timothy Gallwey noticed something like this in the 1970s. The more he told students what they did wrong, the worse they played.
So he said less and did more showing.
He also changed his questions. Instead of asking if a shot was good, he asked questions like:
What happened?
Where did the ball land?
What was the racket doing?
Questions like that promote helpful answers. "Is it good?" doesn't.
Here's how that played out on one of my demos. You can hear both versions in the video.
Version one was me creating like a child. I got the drums in, and they had a little '80s feel, which told me synths might fit nicely. I got some chords down.
I knew slap bass was the vibe, so I programmed a line with a slap bass instrument in Kontakt.
That starter idea felt good, and I could hear what the song could be.
I came back to it later and couldn’t think of any new ideas, and I almost scrapped the demo.
Eventually I started asking myself questions like: what does this need? Or where should it go?
The first answer was easy. If it's slap bass, it needs a real bass player with the right tone.
Then I asked about the synths and about rhythm, because I want this one to feel really rhythmic. That's where funk guitar came in.
Those questions got me to version two. But the questions alone weren't enough.
I also went out and listened to other songs to understand them better, then brought those ideas back to test. I think that's the scientist part too.
If I only sit with my own song, editing gets hard, because nothing new is coming in.
The producers behind Doja Cat's "Kiss Me More" tell a similar story. It started as an old idea, and Doja didn't like the tempo. So they kept the chord changes, sped it up, and rearranged the whole thing.
So what does listening out in the world look like?
Let's think about arrangement, and how a song keeps bringing in something new from section to section.
Two songs I studied this week each have a move worth stealing.
In "Poster boy" by Lyn Lapid, the bass guitar shows up early. Your ear begins to expect it, and a song feels less full without it.
Then in verse 2, the bass drops out. Very low toms take over that space and do the bass's job, but with a different energy. When the bass comes back, you feel it’s power.
In "Cowboy in LA" by LANY, the song keeps a steady vibe for most of the way. Then the bridge breaks the pattern. The bass guitar stops playing straight eighth notes and starts playing chords.
You don't hear bass chords very often, so this moment feels fresh.
If you're working on a song right now and stuck on ideas, one of these could show up in your version two. It's worth a try.
Same goes for chords. If your progression feels stuck, borrow a move like the slash chords in "Brass in Pocket" up top.
One additional rule to remember that'll help you edit freely: Save every version, and never save over the old one.
I'm updating that reminder on my phone and adding a sticky note to my desk: Create Like a Child. Edit Like a Scientist.
🎯 Try This
1. Give one idea that you have 20 minutes and throw everything at it with no judging. Save that as version one.
2. Come back later and ask a question that has an answer: What changed since the last time this part came around?
3. Look for inspiration and try one move. Example: Change the bass tone or instrument for the second verse, or add a slash chord to your progression. Save this as version two, and keep version one.
🔗 BEST LINKS
My Finds:
Max Martin on the toolbox of problem-solving formulas he reaches for when inspiration runs out (Max Martin Master Class, Polar Music Prize 2016)
Twyla Tharp on why you only know if something is useful, not if it's a failure (Andrew Huberman interview)
I use this tool personally every day to manage my busy schedule and big goals. (Superfocus)
In Case You Missed It…
where your instincts come from (Music Maker's Journal)
